If a life insurance company denies, delays, or underpays a claim in Florida, the main recovery is usually the unpaid death benefit. You may also be entitled to interest, and some cases qualify for attorney’s fees and court costs. A proven Florida insurance bad-faith claim can allow recovery beyond the policy amount. If the coverage came through an employer and is governed by federal ERISA law, a different set of remedies applies.
Unpaid life insurance benefits
When an insurer breaches a life insurance policy by withholding benefits it owes, the starting point is the amount the policy requires it to pay you. That could be the entire death benefit, your designated share, or the difference between what the insurer paid and what you were entitled to receive.
Coverage can include a basic death benefit and separate supplemental life or accidental death and dismemberment (AD&D) benefits. Read the policy and any riders together. For example, if the insurer paid a $500,000 basic benefit but denied a $250,000 accidental death rider, the disputed benefit would generally be $250,000. Recovery would depend on whether the death met the rider’s terms and whether an exclusion applied.
Interest on delayed life insurance payments in Florida
When a policy provides for a lump-sum death benefit and Florida Statute § 627.4615 applies, payment must include interest from the date the insurer receives written due proof of death. The statute ties the minimum annual rate to a Moody’s corporate bond yield index as of the day the claim was received. It also provides an 8% minimum if the method of calculating that index substantially changes from the method in use on January 1, 1993.
Keep a copy of your proof-of-death submission and evidence of when the insurer received it. If the insurer later reverses a denial or pays after a lengthy investigation, ask for a written breakdown showing the principal, interest rate, start date, and interest paid.
Can you recover attorney’s fees and court costs?
Winning a life insurance dispute does not automatically make the insurer responsible for your legal bill. Florida repealed its former general insurance attorney’s fee statute, § 627.428, in 2023. The policy’s issuance or renewal history and the timing of the dispute may matter when evaluating whether the former law applies.
Under Florida Statute § 86.121, a named beneficiary who obtains a favorable declaratory judgment determining coverage after a total coverage denial may qualify for reasonable attorney’s fees incurred in that declaratory action. A declaratory judgment is a court ruling that determines the parties’ rights under the policy. This fee provision has specific requirements, so the insurer’s reason for withholding payment and the relief sought in court both matter.
A successful statutory bad-faith action can also support an award of reasonable attorney’s fees and court costs. In Florida state court, certain taxable costs may be recoverable under separate rules, even when attorney’s fees are unavailable.
Can you recover more than the life insurance policy amount?
Florida Statute § 624.155 allows damages that were a reasonably foreseeable result of a proven statutory violation, potentially exceeding policy limits. For example, if you had to borrow money to cover expenses while benefits were improperly withheld, keep records of the borrowing costs. Whether you can recover those costs depends on the legal basis for your claim and evidence connecting the loss to the insurer’s violation. An incorrect denial or a long investigation alone does not establish bad faith.
A statutory bad-faith action also has procedural requirements. One is a Civil Remedy Notice that identifies the alleged violation and gives the insurer a 60-day opportunity to cure. Resolving the underlying coverage dispute may be necessary before the bad-faith claim can proceed.
What about emotional distress or punitive damages?
Emotional distress is generally outside the recovery for an ordinary breach of a life insurance contract. Families evaluating additional damages should focus on the specific legal claim and evidence tying any separate loss to the insurer’s conduct.
Punitive damages are exceptionally difficult to obtain under Florida’s bad-faith statute. The conduct must occur often enough to indicate a general business practice and meet an additional statutory standard, such as reckless disregard for the rights of a life insurance beneficiary. The statute also requires a claimant seeking punitive damages to advance discovery costs and provides for those costs to be awarded to the insurer if punitive damages are denied.
What can you recover if the life insurance was through an employer?
Many private-sector employer group life insurance plans are governed by the Employee Retirement Income Security Act (ERISA). Beneficiaries can generally sue for benefits due under the plan. A federal court may also award prejudgment interest and, in its discretion, reasonable attorney’s fees and costs. An ERISA fee applicant generally must achieve some degree of success on the merits to be eligible. Punitive damages and emotional distress damages are generally unavailable in an ordinary ERISA benefits suit.
Frequently asked questions
What if the insurance company paid the death benefit after I appealed?
Check whether the payment included any interest owed. For a lump-sum benefit covered by Florida Statute § 627.4615, interest runs from receipt of written due proof of death, which may be well before the appeal was resolved. Review any proposed release before signing because its terms may affect your ability to pursue remaining amounts.
What if two people claim the same life insurance proceeds?
The insurer may file an interpleader action and ask the court to determine who is entitled to the proceeds. If you are served, calendar the response deadline and gather the beneficiary designations, policy documents, and any records supporting your claim. The court’s decision may determine whether you receive all, part, or none of the disputed proceeds.
What records help show how much I can recover?
-
The complete policy or employer plan documents, including riders and amendments
-
The applicable beneficiary forms and coverage amounts
-
The claim submission, written proof of death, and confirmation of receipt
-
Denial letters, appeal correspondence, and any payment or interest calculations
-
Payroll deductions and enrollment records for employer coverage
-
Dated records of financial losses you attribute to the delay or denial
Discuss your life insurance dispute with a Florida attorney
If a life insurance company has denied, delayed, or underpaid your claim, contact J.P. Gonzalez-Sirgo, P.A. to discuss what the policy or plan owes, whether interest is due, and whether the facts support any additional recovery. Have the denial letter, policy or plan documents, and any appeal deadline available for review.
Have you or someone you know been denied a life insurance claim? Contact Florida Life Insurance Claims Lawyer J.P. Gonzalez-Sirgo by dialing his direct number at (786) 272-5841, calling the main office at (305) 461-1095, or Toll Free at 1 (866) 71-CLAIM or email Miami Attorney Gonzalez-Sirgo directly at jp@yourattorneys.com or by text at (305) 929-8935.
This article is for informational purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.