Life insurance is meant to provide peace of mind and financial security for loved ones. But when a policyholder passes away, family members often disagree over who is entitled to the death benefit. These disputes can quickly become emotional, complex, and legally challenging—especially under Florida’s unique statutes governing life insurance beneficiary rights.
If you’re facing a life insurance beneficiary dispute in Florida, here’s what you need to know about your rights, common grounds to challenge a beneficiary, and how an attorney can help protect your claim.
Why Family Beneficiary Disputes Happen in Florida
Beneficiary conflicts often arise because policies are purchased years before the insured’s death, and circumstances change. Common triggers include:
1. Outdated Beneficiary Designations
Many people forget to update their policy after:
-
Divorce
-
Remarriage
-
Birth or adoption of children
-
Estrangement or reconciliation
An outdated designation—with an ex-spouse or distant relative still listed—often leads to disputes.
2. Last-Minute Beneficiary Changes
A change made shortly before death may be challenged if there are questions about:
-
Mental capacity
-
Undue influence
-
Fraud or coercion
-
The validity of the change request
These issues frequently arise when a vulnerable person is cared for by one family member or non-family caregiver.
3. Conflicting Documents
Sometimes a will says one thing, but the life insurance policy says another. Under Florida law, the beneficiary designation controls, but conflicts create room for litigation.
4. Multiple Family Members Claiming the Benefit
Children from prior marriages, estranged spouses, or siblings may assert competing legal rights to the payout.
Florida Law on Life Insurance Beneficiary Disputes
Florida has several important legal rules that govern life insurance disputes.
1. The Policy Controls—Not the Will
Florida courts consistently hold that a will cannot override the beneficiary named in the policy.
2. Divorce Doesn’t Always Remove an Ex-Spouse
Under Florida Statute § 732.703, an ex-spouse may be automatically removed as beneficiary in many—but not all—situations.
Exceptions include:
-
ERISA-governed employer-sponsored plans
-
Policies where the divorce judgment required keeping an ex-spouse as beneficiary
-
Federal policies governed by the Federal Employees’ Group Life Insurance Act (FEGLIA)
Family disputes often arise when an ex-spouse remains on a policy after divorce.
3. Undue Influence & Lack of Capacity
Florida law allows challenges based on:
-
Incapacity (e.g., dementia, severe illness)
-
Undue influence (pressuring or manipulating the insured)
-
Forgery or fraud
-
Improperly executed beneficiary change forms
These are fact-intensive and often involve medical records, witness testimony, and handwriting analysis.
4. Interpleader Actions
If multiple parties claim the benefit, insurance companies often file an interpleader lawsuit, depositing the money with the court and letting the family fight it out.
This protects the insurer—but puts the burden on the claimants to prove their rights.
Common Situations That Lead to Litigation
Family members often dispute the payout in cases involving:
• A caregiver suddenly named as beneficiary
Adult children often challenge last-minute changes benefiting a caretaker or new romantic partner.
• Claims involving incapacitated elders
If the insured had Alzheimer’s or dementia, capacity becomes a major issue.
• Suspicious signatures or incomplete forms
Handwritten forms, electronic changes, or missing signatures may lead to legal challenges.
• Children from multiple marriages
Florida’s blended families frequently produce multi-claimant disputes.
How to Challenge a Beneficiary Designation in Florida
You may have grounds to challenge if you suspect:
-
Undue influence
-
Fraud
-
Forgery
-
Lack of mental capacity
-
Mistakes by the insurance company
-
Improperly processed changes
-
Violations of divorce judgment terms
-
Elder exploitation
A Florida life insurance claims attorney can investigate the circumstances, request policy records, interview witnesses, and file the appropriate legal action.
If You Are Named Beneficiary and Someone Challenges You
You still need legal protection. You may face claims such as:
-
Allegations of wrongdoing
-
Attempts to remove you as beneficiary
-
Accusations of exploiting an elderly or vulnerable adult
An attorney can help you defend your legal right to the benefit.
When to Contact a Florida Life Insurance Claims Lawyer
You should speak with an attorney immediately if:
-
A family member challenges your claim
-
The insurer delays payment
-
You receive notice of an interpleader action
-
The policyholder made recent changes you believe are invalid
-
An ex-spouse or stepchild claims rights to the benefit
-
You suspect fraud, coercion, or elder exploitation
These disputes can be highly technical and emotionally charged. An attorney can help protect your rights and work toward a fair resolution.
Final Thoughts
Life insurance beneficiary disputes among family members are increasingly common in Florida. Whether you’re defending your right to the death benefit or challenging a designation you believe is invalid, Florida law provides clear—but complex—legal avenues.
A Florida life insurance claims attorney can explain your options, gather evidence, and guide you through the dispute process to help secure the benefits your loved one intended.
Have you or someone you know been denied a life insurance claim? Contact Florida Life Insurance Claims Lawyer J.P. Gonzalez-Sirgo by dialing his direct number at (786) 272-5841, calling the main office at (305) 461-1095, or Toll Free at 1 (866) 71-CLAIM or email Miami Attorney Gonzalez-Sirgo directly at jp@yourattorneys.com or by text at (305) 929-8935.
