To prove bad faith in a Florida life insurance claim, build a record showing when the death benefit became payable, what the insurer knew or reasonably could have learned, how it handled the claim, and what harm its conduct caused. Florida also requires a specific pre-suit notice and gives the insurer an opportunity to cure.

Start with the denial letter and the complete policy. If the insurer is still investigating, ask in writing what remains outstanding and why it matters. The insurer’s answers, together with dated proof of what you supplied, can help show whether the company had a legitimate reason to keep investigating or could and should have paid the claim.

What Is Bad Faith in a Florida Life Insurance Claim?

Florida’s civil remedy statute allows a claim when an insurer could and should have settled under the circumstances, had it acted fairly and honestly and given due regard to its insured’s interests. The statute also authorizes actions for certain unfair claim settlement practices that cause harm. Depending on the facts and the provision involved, examples include denying a claim without reasonably investigating available information, misrepresenting relevant policy terms, or failing to explain the policy and factual basis for a denial. Mere negligence alone is insufficient to establish bad faith. 

A beneficiary can challenge a denial and recover policy benefits even when the insurer had a reasonable basis to investigate or dispute the claim. A bad-faith claim asks a further question about the insurer’s conduct under the circumstances. A lengthy delay, an incorrect denial, or an eventual reversal matters most when the record shows what the insurer had available at the time and what it did with that information.

How Do You Prove Life Insurance Bad Faith?

1. Establish that you were entitled to the death benefit

Gather the policy, amendments and riders, beneficiary designation, and written proof of death. Depending on the denial, you may also need the signed application, premium or reinstatement records, or employer enrollment and payroll records. Compare the denial letter with the policy language in effect on the date of death. Identify the precise exclusion, lapse provision, or application answer the insurer relies on.

For a Florida first-party bad-faith claim based on withheld benefits, the insurer’s liability for coverage and the amount of the underlying loss generally must be determined before the bad-faith action can proceed. The coverage dispute may therefore need to be resolved first. 

2. Document what the insurer knew and when it knew it

Make a timeline beginning with the date you submitted the claim. For each event, record what the insurer requested, what you provided, when it received the material, and how it responded. Save portal confirmations, delivery receipts, emails and attachments, letters, and contemporaneous notes of phone calls. Ask the insurer to identify any outstanding records and explain why it needs them.

A dated record helps answer a concrete question. If the insurer says it was waiting for a document, can you show when it received the document and what it did afterward? If the reason for denial changed, compare the explanations and identify what new information, if any, the insurer relied on.

3. Connect the insurer’s conduct to the available evidence

Suppose an insurer denies a claim during the contestability period because the insured allegedly answered a tobacco question incorrectly. The application asked about tobacco use during the previous 12 months, and the record cited in the denial describes tobacco use years earlier. The signed application and dated medical record let you test the stated reason for denial. If you sent the complete record before the denial, proof of receipt also helps establish what the insurer had when it made its decision.

An internal claim file may show when documents arrived, who reviewed them, and how the insurer reached its decision. Relevant materials may be obtainable in litigation, depending on the stage of the case and applicable discovery and privilege rules. Your own records can establish much of the timeline before then.

4. Show what harm the conduct caused

Keep records of specific losses you attribute to the improper delay or denial, including dates, amounts, and why each expense arose. For example, if you borrowed money while waiting for a death benefit, preserve the loan agreement, payment records, and evidence linking the borrowing to the delay. Whether a loss is recoverable depends on the facts, causation, and the statutory standard for reasonably foreseeable damages.

For policies that pay lump-sum death benefits, Florida generally requires interest from the date the insurer receives written due proof of death. If the insurer eventually pays, check the payment statement and interest calculation. Florida sets a heightened standard for punitive damages, including a requirement that qualifying acts occur often enough to indicate a general business practice. 

How Does Florida’s Civil Remedy Notice Work?

Before bringing a statutory bad-faith lawsuit, the claimant must give the Florida Department of Financial Services and the insurer 60 days’ written notice. The Civil Remedy Notice, or CRN, is filed through the department’s online system. The statute calls for specifics, including the statutory language allegedly violated, the facts and circumstances, the names of individuals involved, relevant policy language where required, and a statement that the notice is given to perfect the right to bring the civil remedy. 

The insurer has a statutory opportunity to cure. A timely cure can bar the bad-faith action. Where contractual benefits are owed, payment of those benefits can cure the alleged bad faith. The notice and cure process is a separate requirement from establishing coverage and the amount owed. Have a Florida life insurance attorney review the claim record, the proposed notice, and any deadlines before filing. 

What If the Life Insurance Came Through an Employer?

First determine whether the group plan is governed by the federal Employee Retirement Income Security Act (ERISA). When ERISA applies, it generally preempts a state-law bad-faith claim based on the handling of plan benefits. The beneficiary’s options typically include the plan’s administrative appeal and, where appropriate, a federal claim for benefits. Ask promptly for the plan documents, the records used in the decision, and the appeal deadline in the denial letter. Put relevant evidence in the administrative record while the appeal is open.

Frequently Asked Questions

How long can a life insurance company investigate a claim?

The facts drive the analysis. Look at what remains genuinely unresolved, whether the insurer is actively pursuing the relevant records, and when it received enough information to make a decision. A review of an apparent lapse or conflicting beneficiary forms may require additional evidence. Repeated requests for documents the insurer already has, especially after you confirm delivery, can help show that further delay was unjustified. Florida’s 60-day CRN period applies to the opportunity to cure a claimed violation.

Can I pursue bad faith if the insurer eventually pays?

It depends on the timing and circumstances of payment, whether the insurer timely cured after a valid Civil Remedy Notice, and whether you can prove a statutory violation and resulting damages. Keep the payment letter, any interest calculation, and the correspondence leading up to payment.

What should I do first if my life insurance claim was denied?

Request the written denial and the complete policy, including amendments and riders. Save the original claim submission and all communications. Then identify the policy term or application answer the insurer relies on and compare it with the records. If the policy came through work, check the appeal deadline immediately.

Talk With a Florida Life Insurance Claims Attorney

If your life insurance claim has been denied, delayed, or paid for less than you expected, J.P. Gonzalez-Sirgo, P.A. can review the policy, the insurer’s stated reasons, and the claim correspondence. Bring the denial letter, the policy or employer coverage documents, and your timeline so the firm can evaluate the benefits dispute and whether the record supports a separate bad-faith claim.

Have you or someone you know been denied a life insurance claim? Contact Florida Life Insurance Claims Lawyer J.P. Gonzalez-Sirgo by dialing his direct number at (786) 272-5841, calling the main office at (305) 461-1095, or Toll Free at 1 (866) 71-CLAIM or email Miami Attorney Gonzalez-Sirgo directly at jp@yourattorneys.com or by text at (305) 929-8935.

This article is for informational purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.

J.P. Gonzalez-Sirgo
J.P. Gonzalez-Sirgo, P.A.
Post A Comment

Share and Save: