When a loved one passes away, the last thing a family expects is for a life insurance company to delay or deny a claim by accusing the insured or beneficiary of fraud or forgery. Unfortunately, these allegations are increasingly common in Florida life insurance disputes. Insurers often raise them when they suspect problems with the policy application, beneficiary designation forms, change-of-beneficiary requests, or documents submitted during the claim process.
If you’re facing a fraud or forgery investigation, it does not automatically mean your claim is invalid. Often, these disputes arise from misunderstandings, clerical errors, handwriting inconsistencies, or aggressive insurer tactics aimed at avoiding payment. Here’s what every Florida beneficiary should know.
Why Insurers Raise Fraud or Forgery Allegations
Life insurance companies may assert fraud or forgery for several reasons, including:
1. Suspicious Beneficiary Changes
If the insured changed beneficiaries shortly before death—especially if the change benefits a non-relative—the insurer may question whether the signature was forged or the insured was coerced.
2. Handwriting or Signature Inconsistencies
Insurers frequently send a signature on a policy form to handwriting experts. Age, illness, stroke, tremors, medications, or electronic signing tools can all cause natural variations that insurers misinterpret as forgery.
3. Alleged Misrepresentations on the Application
If the insurer believes the insured failed to disclose medical conditions or lifestyle risks, they may allege application fraud—especially if death occurs during the two-year contestability period.
4. Conflicting or Duplicate Documents
If multiple versions of a beneficiary designation or change form exist, insurers may question which one is valid or whether someone altered a document.
5. Family Disputes or Competing Claims
When family members contest who should receive the benefit, insurers may raise fraud concerns to justify delaying payment while they investigate.
How Insurers Investigate Fraud or Forgery in Florida
Once an insurer raises suspicion, they may launch an internal investigation that includes:
-
Comparing signatures to past documents
-
Interviewing family members and witnesses
-
Requesting medical records to evaluate the insured’s mental capacity
-
Reviewing phone, email, or online account records
-
Consulting handwriting or document-verification experts
-
Requesting sworn statements from beneficiaries
These investigations can take months and often result in a delay letter, a reservation of rights letter, or even a formal denial.
Common Problems Beneficiaries Face During These Investigations
Unfair Delays
Insurers sometimes prolong investigations unnecessarily, hoping beneficiaries will give up or settle for less.
Misinterpreting Medical Conditions
An insurer might argue the insured lacked capacity to sign a beneficiary-change form—even when medical records show they were alert and competent.
Incorrect Handwriting Conclusions
Handwriting “experts” hired by insurers do not always provide reliable conclusions. Minor inconsistencies do not prove forgery.
Pressure to Provide Excessive Documentation
Insurers may demand documents that are irrelevant or overly burdensome, which can overwhelm grieving families.
Beneficiaries’ Rights Under Florida Law
Florida law provides important protections for beneficiaries facing fraud or forgery allegations:
1. The Insurer Must Prove Fraud
The burden is on the insurance company—not the beneficiary—to prove fraud or forgery.
2. Honest Mistakes Are Not Fraud
Misstatements must be material for an insurer to void coverage.
3. The Contestability Period Matters
After two years, most policies become incontestable, meaning the insurer generally cannot deny a claim for application misrepresentations unless fraud is proven.
4. Florida Courts Favor Clear, Valid Beneficiary Designations
If the insured clearly intended to name a beneficiary, courts often uphold the designation even if the form had technical issues.
5. Beneficiaries Can Challenge Denials
You can dispute the investigation results, present contrary evidence, and file a lawsuit if the insurer refuses to pay.
How an Attorney Can Help Protect a Life Insurance Claim
An experienced Florida life insurance attorney can:
-
Gather evidence to disprove fraud allegations
-
Challenge handwriting or forensic document opinions
-
Obtain medical testimony about the insured’s capacity
-
Handle communications with the insurer
-
File a lawsuit for wrongful denial or bad-faith practices
-
Pursue penalties and attorney’s fees under Florida law
In many cases, an attorney’s involvement speeds up payment and prevents the insurer from abusing the investigation process.
What to Do If Your Life Insurance Claim Is Under Investigation
If the insurer has sent you a “delay letter,” “reservation of rights letter,” or is asking questions about signatures or beneficiary changes, take the following steps:
-
Keep copies of all documents you have, including the policy and beneficiary forms.
-
Avoid giving statements until you speak with an attorney.
-
Do not admit mistakes—even small ones—without legal advice.
-
Request status updates in writing every 30 days.
-
Consult a Florida life insurance lawyer as soon as possible.
The faster you respond with proper documentation and legal support, the stronger your position becomes.
Final Thoughts
Fraud and forgery allegations can turn a routine life insurance claim into a stressful, months-long battle. But these accusations are often exaggerated—or completely unfounded. Florida beneficiaries have strong legal rights, and with the right guidance, you can challenge the insurer’s tactics and secure the benefits your loved one intended.
If your claim is being delayed or questioned, you don’t have to face the insurer alone. An experienced life insurance claims attorney can protect your rights and help you obtain the full benefits you are owed.
Have you or someone you know been denied a life insurance claim? Contact Florida Life Insurance Claims Lawyer J.P. Gonzalez-Sirgo by dialing his direct number at (786) 272-5841, calling the main office at (305) 461-1095, or Toll Free at 1 (866) 71-CLAIM or email Miami Attorney Gonzalez-Sirgo directly at jp@yourattorneys.com or by text at (305) 929-8935.
